Nicole Kidman recently stopped by the Tonight Show to promote her new movie Paddington, and she shared a story with Jimmy Fallon that she’s been sitting on for years now. Although we’re used to Jimmy playing “Hey, do you remember way back when” live skits with his guests, this is NOT one of those instances. Nicole tells the story of how years ago when Jimmy was on SNL, they both shared a mutual friend named Rick. So one day, Rick was having lunch with Nicole, and Rick calls Jimmy to tell him Nicole would love to meet him — and she’s coming over in a few minutes! True story. You can watch Nicole tell her version of what happened next above. Even though she had a crush on Jimmy, this is one relationship I just can’t imagine LOL.